John Fetterman keeps threatening to ditch the Democrat Party, and the Left’s purity police have stopped pretending they’d miss him.
Now the party is drunk on its midterm haul and counting heads without him.
And Harry Enten just put up one number that shows how deep the grudge really runs.
CNN’s Numbers Man Turned a Senator’s Collapse Into a Comedy Bit
Harry Enten, CNN’s chief data analyst, sat down with anchor John Berman to size up US Senator John Fetterman (D-PA) and his standing inside his own party.
The timing wasn’t random. Fetterman has warned he could walk out of the party if US Senator Chris Van Hollen (D-MD) knocks off Chuck Schumer for the top Democrat job in the Senate. Van Hollen recently launched exactly that challenge.
Enten didn’t treat the threat like news. He treated it like a punch line.
Borrowing a LeBron James taunt, Enten described how Democrats would react to Fetterman leaving: “Oh, I’m really scared! Oh no!” Then he added, “They would say good riddance, good riddance to this guy!”
Then came the chart. Back in 2024, Pennsylvania Democrats gave Fetterman a net popularity rating of plus 56. Enten’s new figure puts him at minus 56, a 112-point collapse in two years.
“Pennsylvania Democrats despise, they hate, hate, hate John Fetterman!” Enten said.
And he looked like he enjoyed every second of it. Mediaite piled on, declaring that the new Democrat majority runs so wide that Fetterman has effectively become irrelevant.
But nobody on that set asked the obvious question. What exactly did Fetterman do to earn all that hate?
The Grudge Has Nothing to Do With His Voting Card
Here’s the inconvenient part for CNN. Fetterman still votes with his party most of the time.
Fox News Digital tallied his record at nearly 90% since he arrived in 2023, and Fetterman himself claims he votes “a 91 percent Democratic line” when every vote counts. The Philadelphia Inquirer found the number slipped below 80% after Donald Trump returned to the White House. Even the lowest count leaves him on the Democrat side of four votes out of five.
And Fetterman doesn’t hide what he believes. In a Washington Post op-ed in May, he wrote, “I remain strongly pro-choice, pro-weed, pro-LGBT, pro-SNAP, pro-labor and even pro-rib-eye over bio slop.”
Strip away the steak and that reads like a Democrat platform. Fetterman backs abortion on demand until birth, gun control, amnesty for illegal aliens, and transgender surgeries for kids. He’s a reliable Democrat vote, the exact kind the party used to throw parades for.
His friend US Senator Peter Welch (D-VT) said as much. “We’re quibbling about somebody who speaks his mind and votes with us over 90 percent of the time,” Welch said.
But Pennsylvania Democrats aren’t quibbling. They’re torching him.
Quinnipiac found the state’s Democrats approved of Fetterman 80% to 10% in January 2024. By July 2026, his approval among them had cratered to 19%, and 57% said he ought to switch parties altogether.
So what set them off? He backed Israel. He kept showing up on Fox News. He said kind things about the President now and then. Democrat strategist Mike Nellis gave away the game in an August essay. “What’s killing him at home is how he spends his time,” Nellis wrote.
Not his votes. His TV bookings.
Fetterman’s Trump-Friendly Act Comes With a 2028 Deadline
None of this turns Fetterman into a moderate, and conservatives shouldn’t mistake him for a friend.
Fetterman faces voters again in 2028, in a state that handed Donald Trump its electoral votes in 2016 and again in 2024. He can read a map. So he plays the Democrat who gets along with Trump and pretends to be a Trump supporter whenever a camera rolls. He even appeared by video at the Republican convention in September and pledged to work with the President.
The act works on one side of the aisle. A New York Times, Philadelphia Inquirer, and Siena College poll in August found 79% of Pennsylvania Republicans viewed Fetterman favorably, a better showing than US Senator Dave McCormick (R-PA) managed with his own party.
But a favorable rating isn’t a vote. When the Senate takes up abortion, guns, or the border, Fetterman’s name still lands in the Democrat column more often than not.
Maybe that’s too cynical. Maybe Fetterman truly soured on a party that turned on him first. Still, a man with a real change of heart usually changes more than his talking points.
Democrats Just Showed Voters How Small Their Big Tent Got
Look past Fetterman for a minute and study the party that just grabbed the Senate gavel.
Democrats rode a wave of voter frustration into power in the November midterms, and plenty of that frustration traced back to a war the neoconservatives talked the administration into. The NBC News exit poll put the “wrong decision” camp on military action against Iran at 63%, and Democrats walked off with 83% of that bloc. Fetterman, for the record, backed that war about as staunchly as anybody in his caucus.
And with a comfortable majority in hand, the party feels free to toss overboard a senator who sides with it the overwhelming majority of the time. His crime was cable hits and a soft spot for Israel.
That ought to tell voters something. A party that can’t stomach a pro-choice, pro-union Democrat who occasionally shakes Trump’s hand has zero room for anybody who questions open borders, lockdown mandates, or government-run health care. The left-wing crowd cheering Van Hollen’s leadership bid sets the terms now, and it hands out loyalty tests the way the DMV hands out numbers.
Washington has watched a version of this before. Joe Manchin of West Virginia sank Build Back Better, endured years of progressive fury while still backing much of the party’s agenda, and finally registered as an independent in May 2024.
Fetterman’s version comes with a twist. His party despises him even though he withholds far less than Manchin ever did.
And the pressure won’t stop with one senator. Every Democrat representing a state Trump carried just learned the price of a friendly word about the President or a seat on the Fox News couch. Expect a lot fewer of both from that crowd, and a lot more lockstep votes for whatever the socialist wing dreams up next, from tax hikes on working families to an amnesty built to remake the electorate.
Back in January 2024, eight in ten Pennsylvania Democrats approved of John Fetterman. In May 2026, he described himself in print as strongly pro-choice and pro-LGBT. By July, 57% of those same Democrats wanted him out of their party.
Sources: Mediaite, “‘Good Riddance!’ CNN Data Guru Says Democrats ‘Despise’ John Fetterman, Don’t Care If He Flees Party”; CNN; Fox News Digital; Newsweek; The Philadelphia Inquirer; Quinnipiac University Poll; New York Times/Philadelphia Inquirer/Siena College Poll; The Washington Post; Spotlight PA; Jewish World Review; Endless Urgency (Mike Nellis); Jamie Dupree; NOTUS via Spotlight PA; NBC News exit poll