The Supreme Court Took Up One Case That Scares the Hell Out of Chuck Schumer

Open-borders lawyers and their friends on the federal bench have fought President Trump’s border shutdown from the day he signed it.

They swear no president alive has the power to slam the asylum door shut.

And Joe Biden left Donald Trump one receipt that says otherwise.

The Supreme Court Grabbed the Case Trump’s Critics Hoped It Would Skip

The Supreme Court agreed to hear the challenge to the proclamation President Trump signed just hours after he took the oath on January 20, 2025. Its title spells out the mission: Guaranteeing the States Protection Against Invasion.

The order declares an invasion at the southern border, suspends entry for the illegal aliens carrying it out, and cuts them off from the asylum pitch that turned the border into a revolving door under Joe Biden.

Officials at the Department of Homeland Security don’t hide what they think of it. “The single most important factor in the President’s success at the border has been this executive order, which he signed on day one,” DHS’s James Percival said. “After successfully preserving this authority in lower courts for two years, we look forward to presenting our arguments to the Supreme Court.”

And the results look like they came from a different country. Breitbart News reported zero migrant releases from the border for a full year, compared with the tens of thousands Biden’s team turned loose every month.

Border agents caught fewer than 9,000 illegal aliens trying to cross in September. Across all of Fiscal Year 2026, they arrested fewer than 137,000, a 95 percent plunge from the peak of the Biden years, according to the report.

But a crowd of activist lawyers looked at that record and decided the President broke the law.

The case carries the name Mullin v. Refugee and Immigrant Center for Education and Legal Services. Thirteen individuals who say they suffered persecution or torture back home joined three immigration nonprofits to sue, with RAICES, the Texas outfit behind that mouthful of a name, out front.

US District Judge Randolph Moss, an Obama appointee, certified a class covering every immigrant who is or would be subject to the proclamation. Then he threw out the DHS guidance and barred officials from enforcing the asylum shutdown.

A Washington, DC appeals panel largely signed off. Judge J Michelle Childs, a Biden appointee, wrote the opinion, and Obama appointee Judge Cornelia Pillard joined her. Trump appointee Judge Justin Walker dissented in part, arguing the President can deny every asylum application and skip the paperwork on claims he’d reject anyway, though he agreed the government can’t send people back to countries where they’d face persecution.

But the appeals court froze its own ruling while the government appealed, so the policy stayed on the books. Solicitor General D John Sauer then asked the justices to weigh in, writing that the proclamation “rests on a commonsense understanding of the President’s inherent and delegated powers to exclude aliens.”

The justices will decide whether the proclamation and the DHS guidance hold up, along with whether Moss had the power to hand down such a sweeping order. They passed on the government’s separate gripe about how the lower court built the class. Reuters expects a decision by the end of June.

RAICES Already Hauled Joe Biden Into Court Over the Same Power

Here’s the part the activists would rather nobody bring up.

Joe Biden waited more than three years into his term to do anything serious about the border. Then in June 2024, five months before an election, he signed his own proclamation suspending entry for illegal crossers and choking off asylum for most of them. He leaned on Section 212(f) of the Immigration and Nationality Act, the same presidential power to suspend entry that sits at the heart of the Trump case.

And RAICES sued him for it. The ACLU filed the lawsuit within days on behalf of RAICES and another Texas group, Las Americas Immigrant Advocacy Center. Lead attorney Lee Gelernt called Biden’s policy “legally indistinguishable from the Trump ban we successfully blocked.”

Now look at what the challengers told the Supreme Court in their brief urging the justices to stay out of this one. “By January 2025, before the Proclamation took effect, border apprehensions had returned to historically routine levels, down over 90 percent from their peak,” they wrote.

Read that twice. Crossings dropped after Biden’s election-year crackdown kicked in. His own Homeland Security Department bragged that average daily encounters between ports of entry fell more than 55 percent from early June through the end of August 2024.

So RAICES went to court to kill the Biden policy, then pointed to the drop that policy helped produce as proof the country never faced a crisis worth a presidential order. That takes nerve. It’s a bit like suing the fire department for spraying too much water and then telling the insurance adjuster the house never caught fire.

Somebody could argue the Biden lawsuit shows RAICES plays no favorites. Maybe so. But all it really proves is that the group objects any time a president, from either party, actually closes the door.

The Biden version came stuffed with escape hatches, too. Its shutdown would lift once crossings dipped low enough, and it kept a side entrance open for migrants who landed appointments through the CBP One app. Trump’s order carries no such loopholes, which goes a long way toward explaining why it worked, and why the activists despise it.

Democrats Want the Border Handed Back to Congress in January

The challengers closed their pitch with a line worth taping to the refrigerator. “If the Executive Branch nonetheless believes it needs new tools to manage the border, Congress must provide them,” they wrote.

Think about who runs Congress come January. Democrats take over both chambers, and nobody should hold their breath waiting for the new majority to hand Trump fresh border tools.

So “let Congress handle it” really means “let the Democrats handle it.” And the Democrat Party’s version of handling the border runs straight through amnesty, a plan to reward lawbreakers and reshape the voter rolls for a generation.

Voters have already picked a side. A Reuters/Ipsos survey from February 2026 found 61 percent of Americans support deporting people living here illegally, and more than a third of Democrats agreed.

The Court also has a shot at reining in a habit that has dogged Trump since his first term, where one district judge in Washington, DC hands down an order that reaches nearly every immigrant who might someday show up. Sauer warned the justices that this class sweeps in foreigners still overseas who have no plans to come at all.

Maybe the justices split the difference. Walker’s partial dissent sketches one path, where the President keeps the power to shut down asylum but still has to screen people who claim they’d face persecution back home. That outcome would leave Trump with most of his weapon intact.

But a full loss would drag the border back toward the Biden years, when catch-and-release ran around the clock. And the new Democrat majority would control the purse strings for every agency charged with cleaning up the mess.

Joe Biden signed his border shutdown in June 2024 with an election bearing down, and RAICES dragged him into court for it. The same group now wants the justices to believe the quiet border his order helped produce proves Donald Trump never needed one at all.

Sources:

Breitbart News, “SCOTUS to Decide Constitutionality of Trump’s ‘Single Most Important’ Border Reform”

SCOTUSblog, “Supreme Court agrees to hear case on Trump administration’s suspension of asylum”

CBS News, “Supreme Court takes up case over Trump effort to suspend asylum access at southern border”

Reuters, “Supreme Court will weigh Trump’s asylum restrictions at US-Mexico border”

American Civil Liberties Union, “Immigrants’ Rights Groups Sue Biden Administration Over New Anti-Asylum Rule”

The Daily Record (Associated Press), “Biden faces first lawsuit over new asylum crackdown at Mexico border”

Department of Homeland Security, “Joint DHS-DOJ Final Rule Issued to Restrict Asylum Eligibility for Those Who Enter During High Encounters at the Southern Border”

Congressional Research Service, “The Biden Administration’s June 2024 Proclamation and Rule, Securing the Border”

The Daily Signal, Reuters/Ipsos polling on deportation support

No Comments Yet

Comments are closed